The whole game is being stolen from. A gift nobody takes is a failure regardless of how much you spent, and the joke gifts that get a laugh on opening are usually the ones left sitting there.
What gets stolen is something the room can immediately picture using. Specific enough to be funny, useful enough to be worth the theft.

Under $16
Poodle Vinyl Sticker: Poodle Hair. Don't Care. Price range: $12.95 through $19.95See it →
Die-Cut Magnet, Lab Tested. Treat Approved, Labrador Retriever Gift Price range: $14.95 through $22.95See it →
Black Coffee Mug, Poodle Gift: Poodle Hair. Don't Care. Price range: $18.50 through $21.00See it →Under $25, the cap most offices use
Ceramic Mug, Mommy Panda Mug, Cute Mom Mug Gift, Panda Coffee Mug, Mother’s Day Gift, New Mom Gift, Baby Shower Gift, I Love You Mom Mug Price range: $19.95 through $29.95See it →
Color Inside Mug, Poodle Gift: Poodle Hair. Don't Care. Price range: $20.00 through $22.50See it →
Best Mom Mug – Mother’s Day Gift, Floral Coffee Mug, Gift for Mom, Cute Mom Mug Price range: $22.95 through $25.95See it →Everything here fits under a $25 cap, and most of it under $20. Order about two weeks ahead of the party.
